An Antique Dealer's Blog: Looking at English Furniture
10/12/2005
I think the only editorials worth writing are the ones that really mean
something to the writer. I often read the NY Times editorials and
wonder at the task of writing several columns a week about something
you care deeply about.
I care deeply about good design. There is good design and bad design (particularly in antiques). There are beautiful things that are timeless, even if they are a few years old and there are unattractive things hundreds of years old.
Editorializing about design is difficult. There are few designers given free reign as there are almost always the client(s) to satisfy and whoever heard of a client having bad taste? Years ago, some clients were in my shop trying to figure out whether a chair was masculine or feminine. I did not sell the chair to them.
I care deeply about good design. There is good design and bad design (particularly in antiques). There are beautiful things that are timeless, even if they are a few years old and there are unattractive things hundreds of years old.
Editorializing about design is difficult. There are few designers given free reign as there are almost always the client(s) to satisfy and whoever heard of a client having bad taste? Years ago, some clients were in my shop trying to figure out whether a chair was masculine or feminine. I did not sell the chair to them.
9/27/2005
Great looking glasses are a scarcity on the market. I went on to a
competitor's site today, a company that I admire greatly, to view their
looking glasses. I was not impressed. Either they have been selling
them like hotcakes or they just haven't been finding good ones to buy.
This the tricky part about being a dealer. You can go years without seeing something great, but you still have to stock something in order to be able to offer some product. It is self defeating to be out of an item that is in constant demand, so you have to offer something.
That is, ergo, the dilemma. As dealers, we all want to sell the best. Anyone worth their salt in this business knows that they have taste and yet they also know that offering something that is just okay diminishes the overall stock.
In the end, the demand for great things is causing the great things to get expensive. I would rather have an expensive great lot for sale than something average that is cheap. The people who understand this are my clients.
This the tricky part about being a dealer. You can go years without seeing something great, but you still have to stock something in order to be able to offer some product. It is self defeating to be out of an item that is in constant demand, so you have to offer something.
That is, ergo, the dilemma. As dealers, we all want to sell the best. Anyone worth their salt in this business knows that they have taste and yet they also know that offering something that is just okay diminishes the overall stock.
In the end, the demand for great things is causing the great things to get expensive. I would rather have an expensive great lot for sale than something average that is cheap. The people who understand this are my clients.
9/17/2005
Enthusiasm for English furniture never wanes, mine that is. My body
says differently from time to time as a sinusitis event of supra
magnitude struck while on the west coast and I still had to make the
return flights home.
All's well that ends well. You can compare your own pain to real suffering, the likes of which truly exists on this planet, and sinusitis, as painful as I felt it this time, doesn't even make the threshold of true suffering. And with antibiotics and a few days in bed, I am now merely congested and getting on a flight to England.
The real problem is the perception of mortality. An ailing body leads one to think on it, and it is not a pretty picture. Make hay while the sun shines and buy as much English furniture before you.......can no longer.
All's well that ends well. You can compare your own pain to real suffering, the likes of which truly exists on this planet, and sinusitis, as painful as I felt it this time, doesn't even make the threshold of true suffering. And with antibiotics and a few days in bed, I am now merely congested and getting on a flight to England.
The real problem is the perception of mortality. An ailing body leads one to think on it, and it is not a pretty picture. Make hay while the sun shines and buy as much English furniture before you.......can no longer.
9/2/2005
When natural disasters like Katrina occur, prayer is one thing, action
is another. May the people of New Orleans get assistance as soon as
possible. My thoughts are with them and I hope our governement is
paying attention.
8/31/2005
When I read that a poll reflects that creationism should be taught in
schools as another interpretation of man's arrival on this planet along
with evolutionary biology, I can't help wonder whether people
understood the questions of the poll properly.
Creationism is myth to explain man's presence on this planet. There are hundreds of creation myths out there so whose creation myth should be taught? Science is science and although it is flawed and cannot reveal every step in the biological evolution of man, it is making an attempt through the scientific method to achieve such an explanation. Creationism requires faith and only faith.
I think every religionist should be happy with their own faith. That is WHAT IS INSIDE. Evidently, few religionists feel that way. They want others to share their faith.
I remember reading about a Seminole creation myth about how man came to be. The Supreme Being was making by baking the human race. His first examples were underdone, the second were overdone and the last came out perfectly. Now that is a good creation myth. Unfortunately, my group were underdone.
Creationism is myth to explain man's presence on this planet. There are hundreds of creation myths out there so whose creation myth should be taught? Science is science and although it is flawed and cannot reveal every step in the biological evolution of man, it is making an attempt through the scientific method to achieve such an explanation. Creationism requires faith and only faith.
I think every religionist should be happy with their own faith. That is WHAT IS INSIDE. Evidently, few religionists feel that way. They want others to share their faith.
I remember reading about a Seminole creation myth about how man came to be. The Supreme Being was making by baking the human race. His first examples were underdone, the second were overdone and the last came out perfectly. Now that is a good creation myth. Unfortunately, my group were underdone.
8/29/2005
The controversy sparked by creationists who believe that man's
existence is due to some intelligent design by a superior being and is
not due to evolutionary biology greatly amuses me. Not being a
biologist, but being someone that looks at and evaluates design on a
quotidian basis, I have only to say that the phrase, intelligent
design, is an oxymoron.
Design is not intelligent. It is an attempt to create a solution to a problem. You may use intelligence to create a solution, but to say that one solution is intelligent and therefore the best or even just satisfactory, misses the point. If we had an intelligent solution to something like housing, for example, we would never alter from it. It would be an "intelligent solution", but we don't have it.
Designers and craftsmen that I know are never satisfied. Any designer charged with creating man would have to be concerned that a better model required just a little more tweaking. Or is that what Armageddon is designed to achieve?
Design is not intelligent. It is an attempt to create a solution to a problem. You may use intelligence to create a solution, but to say that one solution is intelligent and therefore the best or even just satisfactory, misses the point. If we had an intelligent solution to something like housing, for example, we would never alter from it. It would be an "intelligent solution", but we don't have it.
Designers and craftsmen that I know are never satisfied. Any designer charged with creating man would have to be concerned that a better model required just a little more tweaking. Or is that what Armageddon is designed to achieve?
8/29/2005
The controversy sparked by creationists who believe that man's
existence is dut to some intelligent design by a superior being and is
not due to evolutionary biology greatly amuses me. Not being a
biologist, bu being someone that looks at and evaluates design on a
quotidian basis, I have only to say that the phrase, intelligent
design, is an oxymoron.
Design is not intelligent. It is an attempt to create a solution to a problem. You may use intelligence to create a solution, but to say that one solution is intelligent and therefore the best or even just satisfactory, misses the point. If we had an intelligent solution to something like housing, for example, we would never alter from it. It would be an "intelligent solution", but we don't have it.
Designers and craftsmen that I know are never satisfied. Any designer charged with creating man would have to be concerned that a better model required just a little more tweaking. Or is that what Armageddon is designed to achieve?
Design is not intelligent. It is an attempt to create a solution to a problem. You may use intelligence to create a solution, but to say that one solution is intelligent and therefore the best or even just satisfactory, misses the point. If we had an intelligent solution to something like housing, for example, we would never alter from it. It would be an "intelligent solution", but we don't have it.
Designers and craftsmen that I know are never satisfied. Any designer charged with creating man would have to be concerned that a better model required just a little more tweaking. Or is that what Armageddon is designed to achieve?
8/17/2005
Are aesthetics part of the mission statement of a museum?
The arbitrary nature of deciding what exactly goes into a museum and then what gets displayed is the heart of this question. Certainly, historical cultural literacy is part of the agenda and has a sound reason for inclusion, but do aesthetics rate as well?
Imagine a carved fragment of a statue from ancient Greece and being overawed by the beauty, condition, craftsmanship and provenance of it. Then imagine a similar statue of lesser merit--same subject but just not as wonderful but the difference is that it is whole, not just a shard. The whole piece tells a greater story to most museum goers, but the beautiful fragment is what really sings. Which piece would you put on display?
The arbitrary nature of deciding what exactly goes into a museum and then what gets displayed is the heart of this question. Certainly, historical cultural literacy is part of the agenda and has a sound reason for inclusion, but do aesthetics rate as well?
Imagine a carved fragment of a statue from ancient Greece and being overawed by the beauty, condition, craftsmanship and provenance of it. Then imagine a similar statue of lesser merit--same subject but just not as wonderful but the difference is that it is whole, not just a shard. The whole piece tells a greater story to most museum goers, but the beautiful fragment is what really sings. Which piece would you put on display?
8/16/2005
Is this the mission of museums?
My daughter experessed dissatisfaction at seeing a lone Egyptian mummy on display at the Milwaukee Art Museum. She felt it gratuitous, non-sequential and unrelated to the overall presentation. My question to her was how do you hook people into being curious if you don't have some random presentations? (I might add that Milwaukee has a nice English commode that is out of context in its presentation.)
What we ended up talking about is how museums could better present what they have. Historical cultural literacy has so many facets that could be included on a presentation card that it is hard to know what to leave in and what to leave out. Personally, I think museums need to work harder at teaching what they know to the people that are curious enough to want their knowledge.
My daughter experessed dissatisfaction at seeing a lone Egyptian mummy on display at the Milwaukee Art Museum. She felt it gratuitous, non-sequential and unrelated to the overall presentation. My question to her was how do you hook people into being curious if you don't have some random presentations? (I might add that Milwaukee has a nice English commode that is out of context in its presentation.)
What we ended up talking about is how museums could better present what they have. Historical cultural literacy has so many facets that could be included on a presentation card that it is hard to know what to leave in and what to leave out. Personally, I think museums need to work harder at teaching what they know to the people that are curious enough to want their knowledge.
8/11/2005
I felt my deep sleep slip away in the wee hours of the morning rather
like the nylon top sheet that used to slide off me with the blankets
in tow when I stayed in my parents-in-law's guest room in Sussex on
what seemed like every cold and wintry night. You know what is
happening but are too dozy to stop it and then...., well you are awake
by then.
I often think about furniture when I am lying awake unable to get back to sleep. Not always, but last night at least. I am really fascinated by what gets people interested in antiques. I don't see it as affectation--anything but, in fact. It can only be aesthetics. I have seen the gleam come into a client's eye when they are looking at something and I know I have sold the object before they know they are buying it.
That inner light that yields the gleam is what interests me. Where does it come from and why does this one thing, not necessarily the only thing, make them glow?
I often think about furniture when I am lying awake unable to get back to sleep. Not always, but last night at least. I am really fascinated by what gets people interested in antiques. I don't see it as affectation--anything but, in fact. It can only be aesthetics. I have seen the gleam come into a client's eye when they are looking at something and I know I have sold the object before they know they are buying it.
That inner light that yields the gleam is what interests me. Where does it come from and why does this one thing, not necessarily the only thing, make them glow?
8/10/2005
In a discussion with a client and a shipping friend, we discussed the
role of the decorator as it applies to the antiques world. My friend
suggested that decorators were important in steering a client towards a
style when they might not know which way to go. My response was that
people who need to know a style should do some homework. In response to
my remark about homework, the shipper told me about home installations
where the decorator has bought and installed every last thing in the
house.
I esteem the role of the decorator. It is very hard work. I have a hard enough time choosing fabric for my chairs and I only use three or four different fabrics. Decorators earn their money. However, there are people who are clearly more comfortable to let others make choices for them from art and antiques to toilet paper and cutlery. It amazes me that decorators feel capable of doing so much but it is even more amazing to me that people want someone to do so much that is so personal for them.
So much for doing homework.
I esteem the role of the decorator. It is very hard work. I have a hard enough time choosing fabric for my chairs and I only use three or four different fabrics. Decorators earn their money. However, there are people who are clearly more comfortable to let others make choices for them from art and antiques to toilet paper and cutlery. It amazes me that decorators feel capable of doing so much but it is even more amazing to me that people want someone to do so much that is so personal for them.
So much for doing homework.
8/9/2005
The greatest thing about good rock and roll as I listen to my son's
birthday gift of the Killers album, "Hot Fuss", is that it has gusto.
It moves you. Great Kent furniture has gusto--Chippendale was less
inclined that way and Hepplewhite and Sheraton are positively subdued.
Henry Holland, on the other hand knew gusto and as a result, a lot of
Regency furniture has it as well.
Gusto is not a word you would normally use to describe English furniture, but it is an aspect that it can have. Great English furniture has so many different qualities, none of them anthropomorphic in my opinion although I do hear people referring to their furniture in the third person. I guess there are qualities that even I don't know about despite my close affiliation to the subject.
Perhaps this is decadent. I don't think so. I believe it is involvement, the kind of involvement that gives dimension to life.
Gusto is not a word you would normally use to describe English furniture, but it is an aspect that it can have. Great English furniture has so many different qualities, none of them anthropomorphic in my opinion although I do hear people referring to their furniture in the third person. I guess there are qualities that even I don't know about despite my close affiliation to the subject.
Perhaps this is decadent. I don't think so. I believe it is involvement, the kind of involvement that gives dimension to life.
8/8/2005
The exhibition at MoMA of Pissarro and Cezanne paintings is spectacular.
And while you are there, look at the late 19th and 20th century furniture. What Charles Rennie Mackintosh understood and which I don't credit many other architect designers since that time as understanding, is how important vertical line is in creation. His chair and his poster at MoMA both demonstrate this and they are inspiring designs even though the chair will never be comfortable other than as a perch.
This detail alone, at least for me, makes him stand out from his peers and successors.
And while you are there, look at the late 19th and 20th century furniture. What Charles Rennie Mackintosh understood and which I don't credit many other architect designers since that time as understanding, is how important vertical line is in creation. His chair and his poster at MoMA both demonstrate this and they are inspiring designs even though the chair will never be comfortable other than as a perch.
This detail alone, at least for me, makes him stand out from his peers and successors.
8/7/2005
My use of the word tactile to describe one aspect of my business is
slightly off the mark. Sensual is a better word as that is what
engaging objects is all about. I suppose that I could have been a
lawyer or an accountant and made my hobby sensual, but I lucked out and
made it my business.
I visited MoMA yesterday for the first time in years. It was crowded. There was a furniture exhibition of late 19th to late 20th century designs. There was a Mackintosh chair that a classmate of mine at the London College of Furniture copied for her year end project. It has a high back with a an oval tablet held between the two stiles. The through tenons through which the tablet fit were very difficult to cut. It is a beautiful chair, but uncomfortable. There was a Rietveld chair as well that another classmate copied--a cubist conception made of one by ones used as a scaffolding to hold two pieces of plywood that made the seat and the back. The end grain of the one by ones are painted different colors than the rails and seat to emphasize the cubist nature of the design. This chair was also uncomfortable.
Some of the furniture from the last one hundred years such as the Marcel Breuer tubular steel chair works wonderfully and is still manufactured today. Other pieces are exercises in draughtsmanship where the designers seem to either be complementing or competing with the fine arts world. The thought behind them is often clever but as furniture to live with, I can't help but be wedded to the 18th century.
I visited MoMA yesterday for the first time in years. It was crowded. There was a furniture exhibition of late 19th to late 20th century designs. There was a Mackintosh chair that a classmate of mine at the London College of Furniture copied for her year end project. It has a high back with a an oval tablet held between the two stiles. The through tenons through which the tablet fit were very difficult to cut. It is a beautiful chair, but uncomfortable. There was a Rietveld chair as well that another classmate copied--a cubist conception made of one by ones used as a scaffolding to hold two pieces of plywood that made the seat and the back. The end grain of the one by ones are painted different colors than the rails and seat to emphasize the cubist nature of the design. This chair was also uncomfortable.
Some of the furniture from the last one hundred years such as the Marcel Breuer tubular steel chair works wonderfully and is still manufactured today. Other pieces are exercises in draughtsmanship where the designers seem to either be complementing or competing with the fine arts world. The thought behind them is often clever but as furniture to live with, I can't help but be wedded to the 18th century.
8/5/2005
When I speak of connectivity, I am referring to relationships that
objects have to one another and why they are the shape, material and
size that they are. But there is also the relationship that humans have
with objects.
Objects are entirely different in how they touch us. The relationship that we create with an object, it doesn't really matter what the object is, is elemental. Citizen Kane's sled, Rosebud, reverberated in his mind for reasons that we could speculate on until the end of time.
I have a similar sense about English furniture. It is almost a belief system where I trust intrinsically in what I am looking at. My mechanic has that feeling for cars, something I do not nor ever will share. It is the best part of being in the tactile world.
Objects are entirely different in how they touch us. The relationship that we create with an object, it doesn't really matter what the object is, is elemental. Citizen Kane's sled, Rosebud, reverberated in his mind for reasons that we could speculate on until the end of time.
I have a similar sense about English furniture. It is almost a belief system where I trust intrinsically in what I am looking at. My mechanic has that feeling for cars, something I do not nor ever will share. It is the best part of being in the tactile world.